Wednesday, April 21, 2010

The lady thing I won't talk about. Even with feminists.

So, I have been thinking (ahahaha, I know, right?  I NEVER do that).  And it was because of the Jezebel post about the MTV True Life episode, which I just watched, on Body Dysmorphic Disorder.

And, you know, it's MTV, so it's not the most tasteful or thoughtful show, but: I don't really want to talk about reality TV.  I was thinking about how being feminist and being aware of privilege makes me really struggle with my own BDD. 

I was diagnosed four years ago.  It's definitely gotten worse as time as gone by, and exponentially worse after the rape.  It's also not a disorder that stands alone; it ties in to my bipolar disorder, my anxiety problems.  But also, really, what woman DOESN'T have BDD to some degree?  Every woman I know dislikes something about herself, thinks she is too fat, hates her hair, despises her ankles.  It's always something.  And we ladies think, god, if we could just lose that weight, or fix this, or look like that, we would be fine.  Or, at least that is how I think.  I fantasize about being beautiful and imagine I would be that whole new person and have the courage to go out and feel pretty and meet people and find someone to date and get an "A" in every class and everything would be all fucking magical!   And, of course, I know I am full of shit, but I still partake in those fantasies.  Like I bet an awful lot of women do.  For many of us, this is just a fact of being female and moving through the world, sadly.  And the fact that we ALL as women have to manage with these feelings of self-hate means that this is a symptom not of our own, but of some larger cultural disease.  That part is what's easy for me to intellectualize and understand.

But I still wouldn't go to the prom-y type thing my law school has, because I felt too fat to get in a dress.  And even though I love to swim, I won't get in a bathing suit to go swimming at the gym.  And I cannot go shopping without every single time, even when I am thinking I am compensating for my BDD, picking out clothes that are two sizes too large.  And I won't wear tank tops, because my arms are too fat.  And sometimes, I stop eating.  Or I won't go out with people, especially to a party, because I will go and look at all the other women and feel like the ugliest thing that has ever walked the earth and want to run back home and hide.  Sometimes, I will feel so hideous I will not leave my house and cry.  I hate and hate and hate on my body so much occasionally I have consider dying as an option, because then I could escape it.  So I can intellectualize, but I can't get over it.

Good therapy has been essential to managing it (also, to hiding it, let's be real).  I hear that voice in my head and think, "Gayle, SHUT UP NOW."  I know my thoughts are not based in reality.  I know it is a disorder.  I remind myself that there are people starving on this earth, and that I am one of the most privileged people on the planet, and I am not actually physically disabled or have any serious illnesses, and I need to fucking just get over myself already, JESUS.  But I will still purposefully go all day long without looking at my face.  Every time I go to the bathroom and wash my hands at the sink, I will never look up into the mirror.

The disorder is both bolstered by and bolsters my disassociative disorder.  Basically, I cut my head off from my body.  I believe I am a decently capable, smart individual, and I can walk into many situations thinking that I will be able to manage them, or be able to rock them even, based solely on the brain in my head.  I think of it as being able to "head" through things.  And if I don't look in the mirror all day, I can forget my body.  I can forget I hate it.  I can forget that I find myself so hideous, that on some days, I won't walk out the door.

It also feels like the disorder of horrendous privilege and anti-feminism, too.

I mean, lookit.  I am not actually fat.  I'm not thin by any means, but I am not actually fat, not by any standard based on numbers and sizes.  And even though I FEEL tremendously large and disgusting, and when I look in the mirror I think I am gargantuan, I don't get called names for being fat.  I don't get disrespected by my doctor for being fat.  People are not repulsed by my body.  I never have to worry about flying and being charged for two seats.

And that is some serious privilege.  Then there is my feminist shame, because it means that I have lost the war against the culture that tries to tell me I will always be too fat, I have failed to internalize any of the feminist rhetoric about new beauty standards or really embracing my body at any size.  I will speak about my mental illness, my rape, ANYTHING, with other women, other feminists.  But I will never speak about the BDD.  Because it makes me feel like an asshole to even bring it up.

Especially because it means I wish to co-opt other women's illnesses and trivialize them, when I pray at night for the strength to have an eating disorder.  Or I feel like I devalue fat women's actual experiences when I read fat acceptance websites and books, trying to help myself accept the body I am in.  And I look at other women and think horrible things and put them down or hate them and how can I even claim to be a feminist when my disorder makes me so anti-woman?  And when do I get to claim a right to a disorder, when many women suffer from this disordered thinking?  God, Gayle, and there are still people starving in Haiti - why don't I dedicate my energy to fixing things instead of just loathing myself?

It is such an asshole disorder, guys.  For real.  

And so I also hide it.  I won't tell people the extent of it, how bad it is, why I can't go out that night, why I shy away from parties or clubs or dressing up or anywhere I could be judged by my appearance.  And I won't tell people because they almost always respond, "But you're pretty" or somesuch compliment, and that makes me feel worse, but it also makes me think I can't trust that person, because they are so clearly lying to my face.

There are things I do to manage it (once again, thank you, psychotherapist).  I will not insult myself in front of others anymore.  I work on taking compliments.  I try to say a nice thing in my head about every woman I see walking past, because if I am kind to them, I am hoping I will be kinder to myself.  I never look at any magazines other than Harper's and the New Yorker and Bitch.  I do not watch TV, I do not spend time discussing with women what we are putting in our mouths or how we shouldn't have dessert, I remind myself my food does not have any morality attached to it, I try to shut my roommate down when she talks a lot about her weight, and I beat it the fuck up the stairs when my roommates watch The Biggest Loser, which they do ALL THE TIME, that show must air like 3 times a day, I do not understand.

But, I struggle.  And, it's hard.  And BDD takes up a fuckton of my energy, while keeping me from doing things that I would love.  It really came up today, again, when I started thinking about a future drinking date with a couple really brilliant ladies whom I have met through this blog, and I panicked. I had to talk myself through that, because even though they seem so amazing and it will be such a gift to be able to meet them, I wondered: what if they are all so much prettier than me?  They will look down on me.  I will feel bad around them.  Maybe I should not even go.

And that?  Is insane.  I know it is insane.  And I will go and meet them anyway, and they may want to throw something at me when they meet me (ladies, please don't throw something at me, ow), because there is probably nothing wrong with how I actually look, and I am being a egotistical fool.  The asshole disorder strikes again!

And look!  I just wrote a whole long post which boils down to a pity party about how hard it is in my head when I don't actually catch any flak for it in the real world!  GAAAAAAAAAHHHHHH!  I am like the fucking Tina Fey of feminism, people, my LORD.

But, this was part of the reason I started the blog.  I hoped I could drag all the monsters that haunted me out into the light, where I could see there wasn't really anything under my bed all along.  And it was meant to be at first just about rape recovery, but I have come to understand that the BDD contributes a lot to the disassociative disorder, and was really exacerbated by the rape, and in learning to feel ok in the body I am in again, I am going to have to tackle all of it.  Even the stuff I am shamed of.  Even this disorder that makes me feel like I am a giant privileged douchebag for having it.

And that's really it.  You will probably never get me to talk about this in person, because it is a disorder I am deeply ashamed of.  But there it is.  I wrote about it.  I admitted it.  I got it out.  And maybe tonight, the monster under my bed?  Will seem a little less scary.

16 comments:

  1. Buddy, I'm sorry. That sucks a lot. But I think, even if you never talk about this to any person ever again, that you are brave to share so openly. There are somethings about myself (that are just in my head) that I am so ashamed of I won't admit them, not even to myself. What you are doing reminds me of the scene in The Hobbit where Bilbo has to fight Smaug and he is in the tunnel alone because the dwarfs won't go with him to fight; “Going on from there was the bravest thing he ever did […] He fought the real battle in the tunnel alone, before he ever saw the vast danger that lay in wait.” That line has stuck with me since 2005 when I first read it. The dragons we fight on our own that no one else knows about are our hardest moments. If we win a particular battle with ourselves, no one will ever know. If we lose, no one will ever know. It's a lonely thing. It's isolating. Nerdery end-point.

    I commend you for being aware of your own privilege, but I also think you are probably (absolutely) too hard on yourself. Yes, the world is full of suffering. Yes, we are very privileged in not (currently) starving. But you are important too. The things that make you ache matter.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Amanda is right, you are being too hard on yourself. I think you are making it harder on yourself by feeling so guilty. You shouldn't feel guilty, this is a disorder; no one should feel guilty over something like that that is out of one's control. It is good that you are learning to deal with it, and I hope it'll get better. I don't have a disorder, my disatisfaction with my body stems from the very real fact that I don't satisfy society's standards of attractiveness. But it took me a while to realize that my disatisfaction is externally imposed on me, and that I must de-learn it. I think I can empower myself (I've been trying and I think I'm progressing) and that means fighting against society's norms that are imposed on me, but how do you fight against a disorder, how do you fight against yourself? I hope you'll find a way.

    ReplyDelete
  3. You guys, I KNOW. I am super brilliant but only at getting myself into a conundrum. I create an ouroborus of pity/shame/hate like, every time. My mind has masterful ways of managing this.

    It's just gotten WAAAAAY worse since dealing with the rape. So, you know, just walking through it; it's part of healing and all. It is mostly pretty manageable, or like, it doesn't incapacitate me most of the time. But even writing this post brought up all these fucked-up memories I'd forgotten with my mother, and I was like, OH, well THAT sort of explains things, now doesn't it. So even just writing this post was helpful.

    And ASP, I think fighting society's norms are probably just as hard as fighting yourself. Because that was kinda my point - society doesn't reinforce my hideousness to me, once I leave the house. I mean, any more than it enforces the hideousness of every woman.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I also echo the sentiments of the previous posters and feel that you are too harsh on yourself. There is nothing wrong with taking care of your well-being. Also, don't feel ashamed because it is not a choice. While reading your post I kept telling myself how extremely brave you are for writing this. I don't think you are a bad feminist. It is easy to say that one is not influenced by society but the reality is that it is a constant battle against forces that sometimes feels it is greater than us. No one will look down upon you for saying that you are trying, heck, I am also having that battle! This is one of the bravest things that I have read on the Internet, and I thank you for doing it. I hope you get better and take care of yourself.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Awesome post. You know what's funny? Oppression is a bitch. Because just like you feel bad for feeling bad, I feel bad for feeling good. I think I've got, like body euphoric disorder. My image of how my body looks is stuck at about 50 pounds ago. I see pictures of myself and I am like what? That's me? No...I don't look like that!

    But I do. I feel guilty for feeling good about my body, when I am, like capital-F fat, like for real fat. And it's like, what right do I have, to feel good when all these other women who are WAY MORE CONVENTIONALLY ATTRACTIVE THAN ME feel so awful about themselves?

    It's like survivore's guilt or something. For somehow surviving the cultural body-hate onslaught with way less hate (it's there, but it feels miniscule compared to what other women deal with.)

    So we can't win, can we? With the guilt? Although guilt for feeling bad sucks way more, since you have the bad-feeling PLUS guilt.

    Sorry. I think this comment is totally unhelpful. But as I always tell my boyfriend, it's a good idea to try and avoid the second-order badness. Feel bad, but don't feel bad for feeling bad.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Oh, fuck survivor's guilt, dude, that is AWESOME. It was like an amazing day when I discovered: wait, not everyone hates themselves this much all the time? OH. And that women of all shapes and sizes can love their bodies is a good thing for the women in them, for me, for society, for little girls trying to grow up, etc. You have EVERY RIGHT to feel good about your body. We all have that right. Why should you feel guilt about something that ought to be a given? Your comment is TOTALLY helpful, if only because it is good to be reminded that it really is just the disorder in my head, not the truth. But also, seriously, cut that shit out about feeling bad. That's ridiculous.

    Also, I am always attempt to avoid second-order badness. And that only sometimes works.

    But yeah, we get so trapped. The Patriarchy, I think it is cheating. That motherfucker.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Gayle, you're right, fighting society's norms is hard, but I feel as if I have back up, because of this fat acceptance movement that's been mobilizing, because there are others like me who are doing the same thing, you know. That makes it a easier.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I'm glad it makes it easier. I heart the FA movement. It has been a totally revolutionary thing to me, changing the way I think and feel about bodies and beauty.

    And, ladies, thank you, I know it is all in my head and I should be nicer to myself, but I am working through it. If I could manage it, I would, believe you me. Admitting this shit to myself (well, ok, and also to you, but I've never said some of this ever before) was an attempt to start dismantling it.

    Also, ASP, I am amazed you are still awake. Isn't it, like morning there now? You are a rockstar.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Oh God, yes, it's half past 6 in the morning and I can't sleep, my biorhythm went totally beserk over the last week or so - I sleep in bursts of few hours, every 8 or 9 hours or so. It's fucking annoying. I'm going to attempt to stay awake the entire day today and then try to get a whole night sleep instead of the usual 4-5 hours. I hope I make it. :D

    ReplyDelete
  10. Whoa. You are a rockstar! I was right. Good luck, but I am going to bed now :) Have a lovely day!

    ReplyDelete
  11. dude, big-up to you for talking so candidly about something so difficult. i echo all the former sentiments - especially a sane person "how do you fight against yourself?" taking care of yourself is definitely a fight on the side of the angels! i kind of touched on self-image issues a while back when i read a post by a woman with freeman-sheldon syndrome about learning how to love pictures of herself. i really think that the fat acceptance movement and disability studies discipline, etc, are giving us a really rigorous public sphere in which to challenge the hierarchies that dictate who has the right to appreciate their life and love themselves. and seriously, let's go to that law school prom in saran wrap and chuck taylors. xx

    ReplyDelete
  12. Chloe, dude, fuck yes. We will drag my ass to the law prom wearing whatever it is that inspires us that day, and I am all for Chuck Taylors, but I feel like Saran Wrap might get sweaty? Ew.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Hi,

    Thank you for writing this post, as it is exactly how I feel. I too am a feminist but when I am feeling the pressure I will body-snark other women to make myself feel less horrible. I won't/can't leave the house somedays because I have nothing to wear that doesn't make me look fat/fat/fat, and I love to read fat acceptance blogs because they give me hope, but I wear straight sizes so wouldn't actually be allowed to join the community and post.

    So, thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  14. "I feel like I devalue fat women's actual experiences when I read fat acceptance websites and books, trying to help myself accept the body I am in. "

    I think FA is for everyone. It's for me now and thirty pounds ago, it's for the bigger fats and smaller fats, and it's also for all those girls who are really rather thin, but our cultural forces have pushed them into a perpetual fat anxiety. There's a girl I work with who is SKINNY, but she is defensive about the food she eats and loudly comments on the food other girls eat. She obsesses about it. She's made me cry, but I also feel sorry for her. She could be enjoying her body, but I don't think she CAN. I don't think she's having the same problem as you, but she is suffering.

    So sometimes I spout bits of Fat Rhetoric at work, just to get it out in the air that it's okay not to worry about this 24/7 and just accept yourself a little bit. I don't think the big movers and shakers of the FA movement want only a certain poundage to be freed from the pain all of this societal bullshit causes. I think they want everyone to be freed.

    ReplyDelete
  15. FA is really turning more and more into SA or Size Acceptance: the idea that the fucked-up beauty paradigm and everything that goes along with it is bad for everybody. Size acceptance is good for my friend who is almost six feet tall and very skinny and flat-chested, who despairs over having a big nose and not being curvy and "womanly" enough; it is good for me, who is 5'4" and 260 pounds and can't find a fucking pair of pants at Target.

    I hope you can find peace with yourself and, ultimately, with your body; I think you are incredibly brave for writing this post. <3

    ReplyDelete
  16. Thank you, metonymy. Really, I appreciate that so much. I hope I can find that peace, too. It's work, you know? This post was hopefully the first step.

    ReplyDelete