Saturday, May 15, 2010

The stories we tell ourselves.

So, here's the thing that I have learned this week: I am really uncomfortable accessing hard or painful emotional things, things which require me to be vulnerable, when I am feeling physically shitty.

And this is a good thing to learn.  Because I actually haven't really gotten sick since the rapebrain got bad, and WHOA did the getting sick knock out my ability to deal.  Like, I have been crying A LOT.  And I have a lot of health problems, one of them being the propensity to get chest infections, which makes me feel out of control, and when I am already struggling with control issues about my body, this means everything feels extra super painful.  I feel like one giant nerve.  And this post may make me cry, but that is ok, because we are just going there today.

I have been talking to various folks about various things about rape, and I was really struck by how rape interacts with the stories we tell ourselves about ourselves, or about how we expect those stories to go.  And rape pretty much destroys the story you tell yourself about yourself.  And then because your process of dealing rape never seems to track the narrative you think it should, then you think you were not raped, or you are somehow healing "wrong."  So today, Readers, we are going to talk about narratives.

I was actually first raped at 19.  I almost never talk about it; I've never mentioned it here before.  And part of this is I did this weird rapid-eye-movement-therapy-something-or-other, and I have a hard time accessing the memory.  It's like in that Greek myth where to torture the dude, they give him a cup and make him really thirsty but whenever he tries to bend down to drink from the lake, the water recedes so he can never fill his cup.  That's what the memory of the event feels like; when I go to access it, it always pulls just out of reach.

And that's ok?  I guess.  It's weird, and it's a little strange to me that I can't really access a piece of my brain, and my life, but such as it is.   But that was ok with me for a long time, because not remembering it was fine.  Because then it didn't disrupt the narrative I had about myself.

Which was: I am a strong, bad-ass, feminist woman who can take on the world.  And who wants to admit a moment of complete powerlesness and violation?  Not my kick-ass self.  So letting that memory get fuzzy and fade seemed like an ok way to go.  I could keep the narrative of me more intact, undisturbed; I still made sense to myself.

But recently someone asked me if I had ever reported the rape I am currently working through that has triggered my rapebrain (and my therapist now has mentioned I might be suffering from a sort of accumulated rapebrain, from never dealing properly with the first instance).  He asked whether the police were ever notified, I'd ever pressed charges.  And I went, "What?"  And then I gave a bunch of bullshit reasons why I hadn't.  Like, the criminal justice system is really terrible to raped ladies, andI had been in a long-term relationship with this dude, and we'd had plenty of consensual sex, and I knew that could be brought up against me, and he was on fucking probation from charges relating to his drug abuse and I'd been in love with him for a decade and didn't have the heart to turn him in and jail was really not going to help him, since it hadn't yet (this, at the time, was really a reason I never reported.  It pisses me off the most now). 

But those are after-the-fact reasons, mostly, except for the fleeting thought that I just couldn't put the dude back in jail, because he was clearly very ill, and that wouldn't help him (it's true - it wouldn't have.  Whether it would have helped ME is not something I even asked at the time).  But here's the biggest reason I never considered reporting: I never, ever called it rape at the time.

I recognized there was an assault.  A violation.  I recognized that I had been extremely scared and disturbed and felt like I had been really severely damaged in some way.  But to call it rape?  No way.  I didn't call it rape until a friend, sitting across from me at my dining room table last November, two and a half years later, told me I had to call it rape, because that was what it was.

I couldn't handle what admitting I was raped would do to the narrative I was constructing about myself.  Which was: that I was stronger than ever before.  I was braver.  I spoke out more, I was gaining confidence, I could handle my shit.  I was an unabashed feminist and I would never let a dude abuse me.  And since that was my running story about myself, I couldn't allow that I'd been raped.  That would have destroyed everything I believed about myself.

There were several things that went through my head the morning after I was raped (so far as I can remember; shit is reeeaaally fuzzy in my head).  The first one was: That wasn't rape.  The second was: It can't have been rape, I've already been raped (based on the premise the universe can just not be that evil, and no one should have to handle that much.  That premise is, sadly, crap).  And the third one was: I would never have allowed that to happen, and thus it was not rape.

And then I went about promptly forgetting not just all about the incident, but that my rapist had ever existed.  My brain managed an impressive amount Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind type shit, considering I had been in love with the dude for a decade.  I forgot everything about my rapist.  I cut him completely out.  I would remember parties, events, anything, where he would have been there, without him there; the memory remained intact, but he was just erased.  I never thought of him.  I never spoke of him.  Only when a year later he emailed me to apologize for the assault, as that was the step he was at in his latest attempt at a 12 step program, did I remember something had gone very wrong with him.  And then only when I got mad, and was like, fuck you dude, I am not accepting your apology, did I start admitting to others that something had happened, and he had beat me.  But I did not say rape.   

I could manage to tell the story about being hit by my drug-addicted former lover.  But being raped?  No way.  I was the awesome strong kick-ass lady who would have cut his dick off before I let him hurt me like that.  I was bad-ass like that.  So my brain kept up its willful forgetting of the rape part of that night.

Once I was harassed and assaulted in South Africa last summer, though, and started having panic attacks, and massive anxiety, and flashbacks, and nightmares every night, that's when I thought: ok.  There is something wrong with the story I have been telling myself about myself.  There is something missing here.  There is a hole, a gap, a huge bleeding wound that I must have gotten somewhere, but cannot explain.  It's like when you get giant bruises on your thigh and you're like, where the fuck did that come from?  I must have hurt myself, but I can't remember when.

But I started to recall more details from that night, more of what had really happened.  I was able to fill in the lost pieces, slowly.  And then once someone called it rape, my entire narrative about myself fell apart.  It is taking a really long time, still, to figure out how to tell the story of myself and include the rape.  I don't know how to work it in there.  And now that is has thrown out my entire basic premise, seemingly (it hasn't really.  I can be kick-ass and STILL be raped, but it feels like it does) I don't know where the story is going to go.  I don't know what chapter is coming next.  It makes it hard to move forward in life, in a lot of ways, if you cannot move the narrative of yourself forward because the plot has just run headfirst into a brick wall.

So, there's the first hurdle.  How to comprehend your rape when it seems to run totally contrary and completely undermines your own creation story you tell about yourself.  And here's the second hurdle when it comes to narratives: you never fit the acceptable narrative of How a Lady Deals with Rape.

I don't have the faintest idea where narrative comes from.  Law & Order episodes?  Movies?  I don't know.  But, when a lady is raped, she is supposed to feel ashamed and dirty and fall apart right afterward and then have to go through therapy and then she slowly gets better, but always has a tortured experience with sex and trust.   But in this story, the lady identifies that what has happened to her is rape.  She has immediate repercussions from it.  She won't let people touch her from that point on for a long time.  

And that's just not the only experience with rape (I think that narrative is predicated on stranger rapes, which is what society likes to think of as "real" rape, but is not prevalent, as most of us are not raped by strangers in dark alleys who jump out at us, so that narrative then serves to perpetuate that the only acceptable, real rape is stranger rape).  Most women I speak to - they are rarely able to call the rape what it is at the time.  They can't even wrap their minds around that word.  And then maybe it doesn't hit them hard for a while.  Or they actually get angry instead of self-hating.  Or whatever.  But there is this sense that if you did not have the acceptable narrative about what happens when a lady is raped, you weren't raped.  Or you are healing "wrong."  Or, and this was my my thing, you have no "right" to fall apart and be a mess years later.  Because you should be over it now, and you are just being ridiculous, dealing with this shit now.

There's your second hurdle.  It is fighting the narrative of what rape is (not strangers in dark alleys), and how it's supposed to go, for you as a rape victim.  The thing is, rape is pretty much incomprehensible.  There is no way to just DEAL with it.  You have to heal, and you heal in fits and starts, and new, strange emotions and places where you have been cut but thought were scabbed over will start to bleed suddenly, and it will flood you at strange times, and this is stretched over weeks, and months, and years.  It is a process.  And there is always a scar.

But it just never feels like it is valid, if it doesn't match the predominant narrative.  I was able to have sex after I was raped as if nothing had happened.  I didn't lose sleep.  I wasn't disturbed.  I put the entire thing into a box in my head very neatly and pretended it wasn't there, until I couldn't anymore.  It actually took a friend saying that she, too, was only hit hard years later by her rape, to feel like there wasn't something wrong with me, that it was ok for me to be falling apart, that I was allowed my emotions.

And the thing is, I guess that's part of the reason I started talking about my rape.  We need to make room for all the stories.  We need to change the narratives.  We  need to show that we can continue to write the stories of our lives after the rape.  And that none of the stories we were telling ourselves were fantasies; rape doesn't change who we are, at the heart of us.  The story I tell myself about myself has gotten harder, yes.  But I need to learn to tell that story, the story of the kick-ass, take-no-prisoners, force-of-nature, untamable lady that was, also, raped.   Because I am that kick-ass lady.  And I intend for the story that I will write, the one that I am beginning to write now, to be extraordinary.

15 comments:

  1. Gayle, this is an extraordinary and moving post from an extraordinary woman.


    PS. I still owe you (a poem of Tim Burton flowers). I am working on it right now...

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hahaha! That made me laugh out loud. I still love THE POEM OF DEATH.

    Thanks, lady. That means a lot, since I think you are just so stellar and brilliant . . .

    ReplyDelete
  3. A truly amazing post. This blog is quickly becoming one of my favorite spaces in the Internet. I wish you all the strength and courage, something I know you already have.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I second Miss Minx's comment.

    You write so eloquently about things that are so painful. I'm amazed that you are able to articulate these moments of confusion and pain and integrate them into a powerful narrative.

    Gayle Fucking Force!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  5. OMG. I heart you. This post is amazing and incredible and SO crystallizes like, so many things that I have had trouble putting into words and that sound so much better when you say them.

    I don't really have anything to say but AWESOME. It's really true--you want to think that rape changes you, because it's horrible, right, but you weren't changed, because who wants to be changed by rape? So you weren't rape.

    Still struggling with that one. Still don't want to be a rape "victim."

    ReplyDelete
  6. Yes, yes, yes. This is a great post--thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  7. A+++ would read again!

    The narrative about how women who are raped can't enjoy sex anymore really fucked me up, and lately I have been untangling some of the fallout. (Or: trying to untangle it, and sometimes it is okay and sometimes I am a stupid weepy wreck.) I enjoy sex that hurts me a little and where I am playing a submissive role. And for a long time, like four years?, I was convinced that since that was basically what had happened, right, someone had hurt me and I was powerless to do anything about it, and since that kind of sex wasn't ruined for me, it must not have been rape.

    Which is a totally ridiculous thing to think! But I felt like I could either think that OR stop having fun sex that I liked, because as a rape victim I would no longer be permitted to like anything about sex at all. I don't even know how I arrived at that conclusion, maybe it was schlocky TV movies or something. Fuckin' narratives, how do they work. It's pernicious and condescending and damaging, anyway, and whatever is perpetuating it should knock it the fuck off.

    ANYWAY you are totally kick-ass, and did you know that your blog is excellent and important? Thank-you for telling your story even though (ESPECIALLY BECAUSE) it is Different From How Things Are Supposed To Go.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thank-you for sharing your story. There is SO much in here I identify with - enough that it was hard for me to read through to the end. (that by the way is GOOD).

    - those "standard rape stories" aren't even the story for stranger rape. I was raped by a stranger and they don't fit me either. The only part that probably does is the willingness to use the word rape. It is easier to say rape when others will immediately recognize it as such.

    The TV stories of rape's aftermath are invented by people who write about what they "think" rape should be rather than what it really is. But there are in my opinion as many ways to respond to rape as there are to any other major life event, be it happy (marriage, babies, career milestones) or sad (death).

    I also felt that maybe my rape wasn't real rape because my aftermath was different. But again, rape isn't a disease or a syndrome. It is a life experience that must be processed. How we process it depends on what we bring to it. Example: I never had difficulty with sex post rape. But then I was 30 when I was raped and I had a lot of time to think about who I was, how I related to my body, what sex and sexuality meant to me. Plus I'd had good luck with the men I dated and felt consistently respected by them even if the relationships didn't last.
    What I experienced during rape was as far removed from sex, as poison is from food. It used the same equipment and that was all.

    Even people sympathetic to rape survivors can end up putting us into boxes. In reality though, rape cuts too deeply into the fundamental sense of self to reduce its meaning or its motivations to a single paradigm.

    Box 1: Abuse. I cringe whenever people talk about abuse and rape in the same sentence. On self-help sites around the internet and also in newspaper articles the two are regularly conflated. To abuse someone or something means to misuse them. To misuse implies that there was a valid use. But abuse is a wholly inappropriate concept when a stranger has violated the basic rules of human relationships. I also think equating rape to abuse is inappropriate even in intimate relationships. Sex isn't a right between partners. Even in marriage, it remains a gift we give to each other.

    Box 2: Gender. And I cringe when feminists reduce rape to gender wars. The gender construction of rape reflects many rapes, particularly those in social contexts, but not all. Based on what I observed during the rape, the person who raped me is the kind of person who would have likely found rape more attractive the less it was accepted by society. He appeared to be turned on by his power to violate taboos, to dis what others viewed as too sacred to violate.

    - narratives: huge for me. Rape destroyed my self-narrative but narrative has also been the way I have healed. Some of my own thoughts: http://ifshecryout.com/from-victim-to-survivor/

    There is a book I have found very helpful in working through my own rape, largely because it is centered on narratives - what makes them painful and how we can rewrite them in positive but truthful ways. If you are interested, see http://www.resurrectionafterrape.org/ - if you scroll down on the front page there is a free PDF version of the book.

    I still grieve that I couldn't protect myself. I DID fight and got kudos from several different professionals for the way I went about it - lots of different strategies shifting according to circumstance. AND I STILL COULDN'T STOP IT entirely. For years this was a source of tremendous pain to me. I began to heal when some other life events changed my understanding of power and helped me realize that I was successfully exerting power in ways that were not obvious to me at the time. (some thoughts of mine on power: http://www.dailystrength.org/groups/resurrection-after-rape/discussions/messages/8686799 )

    The bottom line is that this journey is personal and no one can tell you how to travel it but yourself.

    ReplyDelete
  9. OK, B., for this:

    Fucking narratives, how do they work?

    you have won the internet for me today. I fucking laughed out loud.

    And maybe I will write a post on this eventually, but I am also pretty submissive? And like pain? And I think that helps me actually work the whole rape thing out. Like, it replaces the rape narrative - subby sex means I am really still in control, and it can be about my pleasure and it doesn't end terribly. I've only gotten triggered when I've tried to be dominant, and, I don't know why. It just upset me.

    Somehow, the illusion, the farce of being controlled, because I am asking for it, can call out of it, and that means the sexual experience is all about me kinda, is really healing for me.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Oh, p.s., and the frustrating thing about being subby and admitting to your partner you've been raped? You'll ask for things, and they'll be like, I can't do that to you, you've been raped.

    This? NOT HELPFUL, gentlemen. ON MANY LEVELS.

    ReplyDelete
  11. i am sitting at work trying not to cry after reading this. This post spoke to me on so many levels. thank you for posting it. I find myself exhausted just thinking about the sheer volume of emotion that survivors (b/c we're not victims, we are survivors) of rape have to deal with.

    With our societies pretty messed up ideas about sex, women's subordination, the issues of being considered "less than", issues with "no" discourse, its hard nowadays to distinguish between what is sex and what is rape sometimes. Which is why i find the whole popular story of a woman wanting to on the night and then changing her mind and suddenly DECIDING that she didn't want it the next day is so utterly preposterous. rape is rape is rape is rape no matter when your brain realises it or how much time has elapsed. and i'd argue that forced sex (where a guy guilt trips you into having sex with them and you grudgingly say yes because it is somehow your "duty"...socialised into not being able to say no? i think so!) has exactly the same psychological effect as rape. i had a similar experience. your not alone!!
    you have amazing strength in blogging this.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Thank you very much for writing this.

    I'm not sure where it fits into what I need to know, but there's something about that very clear description of repressed memories....

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thank you. I was forwarded this post of yours from a friend. It's been 4 1/2 weeks since I was raped, and then realized that actually, I'd been being raped in that relationship consistently.

    I was actually thinking 3 days ago about narratives and what I might have said as a child about rape. I imagined that I would have said "I'd never let anyone do something like that to me!" and not understanding in my kid brain why someone might not report it, or press charges, or even understand the event as the definition of rape. Then I imagined myself as the adult I am now, trying to explain it to myself as a child. What a convoluted conversation. But the great thing is, my child self, without accepting the vagaries and nuances of the situation, can be my advocate. And my adult self, can do the feeling and processing and think about whether my explanations for why it isn't so clear cut, actually make any sense.

    Thank you again.

    ReplyDelete
  14. @chutzpahgrrl, much love to you. If you ever would like to, feel free to email.

    And if there's any way that I can help you, please let me know.

    ReplyDelete
  15. You are indeed a strong, bad-ass, feminist woman who can take on the world. I feel so much respect for you, and am so grateful for discovering this blog. Thank you.

    ReplyDelete